Is Christian Faith Supernatural? Christian belief says its beyond something nature can give you and it comes from God
Faith for the Christian is more than belief but is a relationship with and
commitment to God. Faith can be misleading and even dangerously so. So religion
likes to say that it is not faith that matters but who the faith is placed in.
That is a clever game with words. It is clear that faith matters even if the
being you have faith in matters even more. It is clear that you might prefer
faith in God to God for God is not faith. Faith can be an idol in itself or if
it is placed in the wrong thing or in an unworthy version of God. The Bible
fulminations against idolatry are rooted in that realisation.
The person who thinks his faith is planted and inspired by God in him is a
self-announcer. Like Muhammad and other false prophets, he announces that he
speaks for God. He may not act like a prophet to others but he is one to himself
and he is still a self-announcer. Self-announcing is a dubious activity
especially in matters of spirituality or religion. Revelations based on your
word only are no revelations.
Faith that is not based on reason is not faith at all. Such faith is really
based on not wanting to know what is true.
If God gives you reason and you despise reason in order to have religious faith
then that faith is mere hypocrisy. If you really believe in God you should
respect his gift of reason.
Faith is perceiving something to be likely to be true with the eyes of reason.
Belief can be reasonable even if it is wrong. As long as you are going by the
best light you have it is reasonable for you, though not reasonable objectively,
and as far as reality is concerned. Belief can be wrong.
The traditional Catholic doctrine about the relationship between faith and
reason is totally unacceptable. It says that faith is reasonable and is a
supernatural gift of God but if faith is caused by our reason then it is not
supernatural. Or if it is partly caused by our reason it is partly supernatural
at most.
The famous, A Catechism of Christian Doctrine tells us that, “Faith is a
supernatural gift of God, which enables us to believe without doubting whatever
God has revealed” (page 4, Question 9). Supernatural gift is often referred to
as grace. Grace is a magical gift from God. It can magically turn us into good
people.
Religion erects faith on mysteries – on what appears to be contradictions which
it says are not contradictions. Being unable to believe in the incoherent you
can only do it by magic. Religion has to teach that grace is the cause of faith
and not just logic. But the two conflict and cannot endure one another.
Reason for Catholics is like a ladder that you use to get to faith the gift. And
once you have arrived at the top and reached the goal you dump the ladder. But
if reason leads you to faith then by abandoning reason then you forsake faith.
You are saying that reason is wrong which really denies the existence of truth
and if there is no truth there is no faith. If reason is just to be used to
psychologically prepare you for faith then you merely believe because you feel
it is all true. But you believe and know that feelings do not mean that
something is likely so this faith is a sham. Only a true bigot bases faith on
feelings.
The curious religious notion of the relationship between reason and faith tells
us that faith is not about God revealing himself to you. It is about God
revealing doctrines or propositions to you. Some find fault with it for that.
But some say reason and emotion can be used by God to reveal himself to you. How
else is he going to do it? To experience God as love is to receive the doctrine
that he is love so there is no way one can get away from it. Vatican 2 insisted
that revelation is not about revealing doctrines but about revealing God. This
is impossible.
The doctrine that faith is a gift from God is dangerous. It leads to people
lying that the belief makes sense. It will lead to fanatical sectarianism. It
will lead people to the horrors of faith that refuses to be supported by reason.
Don't forget that if your faith is unreasonable that will not stop you saying it
is reasonable! Unreasonable people always try to seem reasonable.
It is unfair to use reason to get to faith and then to get rid of reason. If
reason is right then one should not start treating it as wrong when one thinks
one has the gift of faith.
You never know when to push away the ladder for you never know if your faith has
attained the supernatural level yet or not or is supernatural enough. The
doctrine presupposes an arrogant attitude that claims to know what God is doing
or has done. All Christians feel that God has supernaturally convinced them of
something only to find out that he has not for it turned out to be wrong.
If faith is the goal then reason is inferior and deserving of less respect. If
reason is the ladder to faith, one should force others to hear the rational
arguments for faith so that they can freely accept God’s gift of faith. The
history of the Churches is littered with evidence that the Church believed it
had the right to shove the Bible and Church decrees down the throats of
sceptics. To denigrate reason is to denigrate persons for reason is the main
part of being a person and without it there is no liberty. If reason is bad so
is liberty. Read this again. Learn from it why you should not let religion
thrive.
The religious say that blind beliefs are right or should be believed. But if
they ought to have beliefs that have no foundation then everybody else should do
the same and have different or even opposite ones if they want. Such faith is
sheer arrogance and bigotry. For one blind-believer to say to another, “I
command you in the name of God and on the authority of my God to believe what I
believe,” is to be a snob. Don't forget that those who use the following
wording, "God commands you to believe what I believe" is saying the same thing.
They are still declaring their own authority to speak for God.
The Christian religion says that faith in it is a gift from God. God enables you
to believe. But if you have free will then he does not need to. And if you
cannot believe unless he does something to you then he has prevented you from
believing before that. He has forced you not to believe. He has forced you to be
wrong and accordingly cannot be trusted. It is an odd kind of free will that
only works when God interferes with it by infusing grace.
Now how would God make a person who is free believe? If he shoves the will then
he is forcing you to be able to choose whether or not you will believe. But that
means that you were not free to choose to believe before that.
The notion of faith as a gift from God implies that we need God to give us
faith. Christianity says faith needs to be a gift to be any good. Without God
giving it, it means nothing.
So we don't have the free will to believe properly. God has to do the work for
us and put the belief in us like it was a vitamin injection to the soul. Faith
makes us more free. We must have had partial free will before. Or perhaps we
could have believed but evilly didn’t want to.
God should be limiting the free will of men like Hitler instead of trying to
stop people from having the truth and its benefits. Believers like to blame man
not God for unbelief. If you suppose that unbelievers resist belief and faith
then that idea can only fuel inter-religious strife. For example, the Catholics
will hate the Protestants if they think the Protestants knowingly oppose
Catholic truth for then it would follow that the Catholics are being shot in
Northern Ireland because of a Protestant system of religion that is not even
sincere and loves trouble. And vice versa. If belief was resisted though we
thought we wanted it then clearly God must have in some way forced it on us
without us noticing. The idea of force is the Protestant doctrine that God pulls
human strings to make people get saved by choosing to be with God forever thanks
to the death of Christ paying for their sins and making them clean.
Faith is the reason religion does harm. Faith is bad in itself and risky and
religion nurtures and reinforces it. There is plenty of evidence of people with
shallow religious faith putting themselves and their children at risk. They do
it for faith. The antics at some Catholic pilgrimage sites is a good example.
The observation that not all religious people are violent means nothing when
faith is the problem. It is luck you can thank that their faith has not ruined
them. It is not their faith or their religion you can thank.
Faith if merely human will cause problems. You may see your faith as a sharing
of information with God, that God is inspiring you about what to think and this
will impact on what you do. You do what you think. But this increases the risk
of faith causing problems. A human faith can be torn down but if you think you
are told by God in your heart what to believe it will be a wonder if you ever
question that faith. If the faith is caused by your imagination and you think
you are taking God's word for it that your faith is right and from him you are
resolving to make this faith depend on his testimony and nothing else. It is
protected from being shown to be your own creation or nonsensical or both.
1 Corinthians 14:37 has Paul the apostle stating that if a person is a prophet
or spiritual he will see that what Paul decreed is a command from Jesus. This an
example of how faith can be used to make you think you know what you do not
know. Notice how Paul implicitly insults the person who feels that God is
telling them that Paul is wrong! You are only spiritual or speaking for God if
you agree with Paul!
The doctrine that we need faith as a gift from God simply proves there is no God
for it implies that human free will cannot be blamed for the evils in the world.
The blame must be squarely placed at the feet of God. He left us unable to
believe the truth by our own powers and reason meaning he is to blame for all
the messes this results in.
The burden of proof that supernatural faith is possible rests on those who
assert that they have such faith. If you claim a pink elephant appeared to you
and blessed you, it is up to you to show this is probably true. It is not up to
anybody else to prove it untrue. Believers then are being unfair. They expect
you to take their word for it that their faith is a miraculous gift. Thus they
are cheating you. Their faith can only lead to lies and hypocrisy even if their
faith has no errors! If the faith is man-made or delusional the problems will be
worse.
Faith can be vague for some. For others it has a very specific content regarding
what one is to think, believe and do. That is why the Catholic faith is
different from the Muslim faith. Saying faith is supernatural is the perfect way
to deter a Catholic from doubting or a Muslim from doubting. They think they are
calling God a liar if they do that and think they have no right to question
God's teaching for God is smarter than them. It is manipulation. The price you pay
for thinking as the Church does is in claiming to know God as well as God does
so that you know he really implanted the faith in you. Man mistaking his
thoughts for the thoughts of God is arrogance.
The Church accepts the biblical statement that when the gift of tongues increases faith it is from God. This is a denial that God really has strange ways because if he had he would occasionally give the gift to decrease faith. The Church is insinuating that faith is more important than anything else which is nonsense and is really about the Church trying to dictate to you what you should want. The Church says that the faith that is right is the faith that God wants you to have meaning that delusional faith that makes you happier is not his will. So all he really cares about is himself. And it is also insinuated that you are more valuable in this world if you have the Catholic faith – don’t listen to the put-off that the Church regards all people as equal as persons because it is how people are treated that matters the most and the Church sees itself as having the right to insult them.
With the over the top concern the Church has for faith it is clear that it is not God that is making the fuss but the Church in order to get manipulating
people’s desires and opinions. Politicians are terribly
corrupt so why should the Church be any different? The Church would naturally be
worse for even the politicians do not try to tell you what to think and they
don’t use mind-control techniques such as trying to indoctrinate young
impressionable children which the Church does.
The doctrine that faith is a supernatural gift from God is irrational and
harmful. It is the key to terrible things and leads to people imagining they
know what they do not really know. If a lad is accused of murder, his
mother will not believe it because she loves him. She will do so if there is
some evidence. But what if good and compelling evidence of his innocence comes
up? She will believe it because she loves him. Does this imply bias? Does it
imply blindness to the truth? Does it affect her competence for assessing
the truth? No – her evaluation of the evidence and what it points to is accurate.
Can we compare this to people trusting in God and religion when evidence against
them emerges? No. She has evidence that her son is a good person for she lives
with him. She cannot even have coffee with God so what she knows about him is
only in her head. The very definition of exploitation and weaponising is
using a person who is not speaking for themselves to get goals such as spiritual
fulfillment or whatever. Jesus and God are not respected by Christians as
deities but as tools.
BOOKS CONSULTED
A Catechism of Christian Doctrine, Catholic Truth Society, London, 1985
A Common Faith, John Dewey, Yale University Press, Connecticut, 1968
A Primer of Necessary Belief, Dawson Jackson ,Victor Gollancz Ltd, London, 1957
Apologetics and Catholic Doctrine, M H Gill and Son Ltd, Dublin, 1954
Faith and Ambiguity, Stewart R Sutherland, SCM Press, London, 1984
God and Philosophy, Antony Flew, Hutchinson, London, 1966
In Defence of the Faith, Dave Hunt, Harvest House, Eugene Oregon, 1996
On Being a Christian, Hans Kung, Collins/Fount Paperbacks, Glasgow, 1978
Oxford Dictionary of Philosophy, Simon Blackburn, Oxford University Press, 1996
Reason and Belief, Bland Blanschard, London, George Allen and Unwin Ltd, 1974
Reason and Religion, Anthony Kenny, Basil Blackwell Ltd, Oxford, 1987
The Balance of Truth, EI Watkin, Hollis & Carter, London, 1943
The Case Against Christ, John Young, Falcon Books, London, 1971
The Faith of a Subaltern, Alec de Candole, Cambridge University Press, 1919
The Fundamental Questions of Philosophy, A.C. Ewing, Routledge and Kegan Paul,
London, 1985
The Future of Belief Debate, Ed Gregory Baum, Herder and Herder, New York, 1967
The Student’s Catholic Doctrine, Rev Charles Hart BA, Burns & Oates, London,
1961
Unblind Faith, Michael J Langford, SCM, London, 1982
What Do Existentialists Believe? Richard Appignanesi, Granta Books, London, 2006
What is Christianity? Very Rev W Moran DD, Catholic Truth Society of Ireland,
Dublin, 1940
What is Faith? Anthony Kenny, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1992