When you sincerely do great evil...
Himmler believed he should inflict horrors on innocent people because his leader
persuaded him it was best for Germany. This does not excuse what he did (page
14, Ethics: The Fundamentals, Julia Driver, Blackwell Publishing, Oxford, 2007)
or anybody who approves of what he did. Islam and Christianity with their
doctrine that certain sinners such as heretics or homosexuals will suffer in
Hell forever without any hope of release just make a caricature of that
principle. They approve of the horrors these sinners may face. And they manage
to make fools consider this not only excusable but laudable.
The Christians would do what God does if they were God. Worship involves adoring
God and wishing one was as like him as possible. They would damn you to Hell if
they could become God.
Christians say you can’t blame God if you get a heart attack for you should have
gone easy on the fries and the beer. It is only right that if anybody is to be
blamed it should be God. The person should get the benefit of the doubt. After
all many people eat bad diets and have a long lifespan. The Christians use God
as an excuse for condemning somebody who cannot change the past. They have to
blame to justify or soft-soap God's cruelty.
Himmler had no rational grounds for his appalling belief. The believer in God
need not worry about rational grounds. He can say that God makes it best and
therefore right for him to eliminate innocent people. The believer then should
be less rational and more dangerous than Himmler. Himmler was not behaving like
an unbeliever in God. We all know we live in an insecure world and that the
thought that we are wholly in control is a delusion. If Himmler felt he could do
things that made his own existence highly unsafe, he must have felt that he
would be protected from the dangers. He might not articulate this as devotion to
God. Not all belief in God and devotion to him and trust in him needs to be
explicit. But he was clearly acting as a religious person. The atheist monster
may not be as atheist as we are encouraged to think.
The view that if somebody has harmful religious beliefs that it is none of our
business as long as they are sincere is wrong. If it would be our business if
they were insincere then the fact that they are sincere makes them more
dangerous. It is even more our business then! At least if they are insincere
they know they are wrong and on the side of wrong. The whole point of it being
our business is stopping the harm. It is not about interfering with their
intentions as intentions for we can't change anybody's intentions for them.
Belief in God endangers morality and our sense of right and wrong. If you
suppose that the belief has no relevance to morality then it follows that
emphasising God like religionists do is bad. The more you emphasise, the worse
it is. You cannot be truly good if you dwell on God more than on what is going
to motivate you to live a better life.