THE POPE IS NOT ANOTHER PETER AND IS NOT THE VICAR OF CHRIST OR THE HEAD OF THE CHURCH
Jesus supposedly made the apostle Peter the head of the Church. He
called him rock but rock does not mean Peter had to be a pope and ruler and
lawmaker of the Church. And he gave Peter the power to bind and loose
which was odd for he never used such powers himself. Jesus himself never
acted like a pope so how could he put Peter in a sense in his place? This
story appears in Matthew 16 alone. In Mark's parallel account, Peter just
calls Jesus the Christ the son of God and Jesus does not mention him becoming a
rock or anything like it. And we are told that Mark was a close follower
of Peter!
The Peter thing is the bedrock of Catholicism and its strange doctrines and
practices for they try to prove it to prove that the teaching authority of the
Church is divine and legitimate. The Church does not have good enough evidence
for such a serious claim. If the Peter rock theory is wrong then Protestantism
is the only alternative. Rome has to decide if it is totally blasphemous and
antichrist to put so much at stake over honouring a man. That puts the Church in
excessive danger of apostasy or of having done so. Now, think. Only Matthew 16
seems to prove the papacy. That tells us that there is only one testimony,
Matthew’s, if he means Jesus wanted a papacy. But the Bible says that religious
doctrine regarding faith and morality are more important than people being
unjustly punished by the law. The Bible says that at least two firsthand and
reliable and independent witnesses are required before an accusation can be
listened to. This means that Matthew 16 does not bear the authority of God if it
institutes a papacy. It could be that the Bible teaches that only accounts that
have the backing of at least one other testimony are divinely inspired for there
is no point in God inspiring anything else. I don’t think this view can be
accepted by believers for only one testimony, Isaiah’s, came for the prophecies
in the book of that name and there are countless other examples of the rule
being flouted and the result still being supposed to be the word of God. But at
the same time the view is correct. The Bible does not want to be looked at as
non-inspired when it is down to one witness accounts. The law of two witnesses
could be telling us that whatever the right understanding of Matthew 16 is that
it is not about the creation of a papacy for nothing else says that Peter was
the head of the Church. It is either not about the papacy or the chapter has
been changed and corrupted for it can’t be inspired. The same can be said about
the likes of John 6 that is supposed to prove that Jesus turns communion bread
and wine into his literal flesh and blood and the verse in John that seems to
say Jesus gave the Church the power to forgive sins.
Jesus, as the Mormon Church has pointed out, says nothing at all about the
Church built on the rock as being a Church on earth. The Mormons believe that
Jesus when he said that the gates of Hell would never overcome his Church meant
that even if the Church ceased to exist on earth it would exist in Heaven.
Catholics assume that Jesus meant the Church would always exist on earth and be
built on the rock of Peter and the papacy. Mormons say that Jesus spoke of the
gates of Hell fighting his Church which means he was thinking primarily of the
Church in the spirit world for Hell was part of the Spirit world. They say that
Satan need not necessarily approve of every human effort to destroy the Church.
They say there is no need to believe he is behind all such activity. They say
Jesus mentioned only Hell fighting the Church and not people which implies he
was not primarily thinking of the Church on earth. If so, then Peter was not the
earthly rock that the Church was built on. Jesus talks about giving Peter the
keys of the kingdom of Heaven - again seemingly thinking of the spirit world.
The idea of Peter being pope in the spirit world is ridiculous.
If Peter was the head of the Church that means he was head apostle. An apostle
was a missionary who saw the risen Jesus and Jesus supposedly appointed twelve
official ones. Only a person who lived in the world at the time of Jesus and
witnessed his miracles and his goodness could be an apostle. The Pope cannot be
Peter’s successor for the Pope is not an apostle.
All the evidence is for the Catholic understanding of You are Peter and on this
Rock I will build my Church as being a fraud. That the Church uses the verse to
prove the papacy was created by Christ though it has been refuted time and time
again speaks volumes.
BOOKS CONSULTED
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS CATHOLICS ARE ASKING, Tony Coffey, Harvest House
Publishers, Oregon ,2006
A CONCISE HISTORY OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH, Thomas Bokenkotter, Image Books, New
York, 1979
A HANDBOOK ON THE PAPACY, William Shaw Kerr, Marshall Morgan & Scott, London,
1962
A WOMAN RIDES THE BEAST, Dave Hunt Harvest House Eugene Oregon 1994
ALL ONE BODY – WHY DON’T WE AGREE? Erwin W Lutzer, Tyndale, Illinois, 1989
ANTICHRIST IS HE HERE OR IS HE TO COME? Protestant Truth Society, London
APOLOGIA PRO VITA SUA, John Henry Newman (Cardinal), Everyman’s Library,
London/New York, 1955
BELIEVING IN GOD, PJ McGrath, Millington Books in Association with Wolfhound,
Dublin, 1995
BURNING TRUTHS, Basil Morahan, Western People Printing, Ballina, 1993
CATHOLICISM AND CHRISTIANITY, Cecil John Cadoux, George Allen & Unwin Ltd, 1928
CATHOLICISM AND FUNDAMENTALISM, Karl Keating, Ignatius Press, San Francisco,
1988
DAWN OR TWILIGHT? HM Carson, IVP, Leicester, 1976
DIFFICULTIES, Mgr Ronald Knox and Sir Arnold Lunn, Eyre & Spottiswoode, London,
1958
ENCOUNTERS OF THE FOURTH KIND, Dr RJ Hymers, Bible Voice, Inc, Van Nuys, CA,
1976
FROM ROME TO CHRIST, J Ward, Irish Church Missions, Dublin
FUTURIST OR HISTORICIST? Basil C Mowll, Protestant Truth Society, London
GOD’S WORD, FINAL, INFALLIBLE AND FOREVER, Floyd McElveen, Gospel Truth
Ministries, Grand Rapids, MI, 1985
HANDBOOK TO THE CONTROVERSY WITH ROME, Karl Von Hase, Vols 1 and 2, The
Religious Tract Society, London, 1906
HANS KUNG HIS WORK AND HIS WAY, Hermann Haring and Karl-Josef Kuschel,
Fount-Collins, London, 1979
HITLER’S POPE, THE SECRET HISTORY OF PIUS XII, John Cornwell, Viking, London,
LONDON 1999
HOW SURE ARE THE FOUNDATIONS? Colin Badger, Wayside Press, Canada
HOW DOES GOD LOVE ME? Martin R De Haan II, Radio Bible Class, Grand Rapids,
Michigan, 1986
INFALLIBILITY IN THE CHURCH, Patrick Crowley, CTS, London, 1982
INFALLIBLE? Hans Kung, Collins, London, 1980
IS THE PAPACY PREDICTED BY ST PAUL? Bishop Christopher Wordsworth, The Harrison
Trust, Kent, 1985
LECTURES AND REPLIES, Thomas Carr, Archbishop of Melbourne, Melbourne, 1907
NO LIONS IN THE HIERARCHY, Fr Joseph Dunn, Columba Press, Dublin, 1994
PAPAL SIN, STRUCTURES OF DECEIT, Garry Wills, Darton Longman and Todd, London,
2000
PETER AND THE OTHERS, Rev FH Kinch MA, Nelson & Knox Ltd, Townhall Street,
Belfast
POPE FICTION, Patrick Madrid, Basilica Press, San Diego California 1999
PUTTING AWAY CHILDISH THINGS, Uta Ranke-Heinemann, HarperCollins, San Francisco,
1994
REASON AND BELIEF, Brand Blanschard, George Allen & Unwin Ltd, London, 1974
REASONS FOR HOPE, Editor Jeffrey A Mirus, Christendom College Press, Virginia,
1982
ROMAN CATHOLIC CLAIMS, Charles Gore MA, Longmans, London, 1894
ROMAN CATHOLIC OBJECTIONS ANSWERED, Rev H O Lindsay, John T Drought Ltd, Dublin
ROMAN CATHOLICISM, Lorraine Boettner, Presbyterian and Reformed Publishing
Company, Phillipsburg, NJ, 1962
SECRETS OF ROMANISM, Joseph Zacchello, Loizeaux Brothers, New Jersey, 1984
ST PETER AND ROME, J B S, Irish Church Missions, Dublin
THE CHURCH AND INFALLIBILITY, B C Butler, The Catholic Book Club, London,
undated
THE EARLY CHURCH, Henry Chadwick, Pelican, Middlesex, 1987
THE HISTORY OF CHRISTIANITY, LION BOOKS, Herts, 1977
THE LATE GREAT PLANET EARTH, Hal Lindsay, Lakeland, London, 1974
THE PAPACY IN PROPHECY! Christadelphian Press, West Beach S A, 1986
THE PAPACY ITS HISTORY AND DOGMAS, Leopold D E Smith, Protestant Truth Society,
London
THE PETRINE CLAIMS OF ROME, Canon JE Oulton DD, John T Drought Ltd, Dublin
THE PRIMITIVE FAITH AND ROMAN CATHOLIC DEVELOPMENTS, Rev John A Gregg, BD, APCK,
Dublin, 1928
THE SHE-POPE, Peter Stanford, William Hienemann, Random House, London, 1998
THE VATICAN PAPERS, Nino Lo Bello, New English Library, Sevenoaks, Kent, 1982
TRADITIONAL DOCTRINES OF THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH EXAMINED, Rev CCJ Butlin,
Protestant Truth Society, London
VICARS OF CHRIST, Peter de Rosa, Corgi, London, 1993
WAS PETER THE FIRST POPE? J Bredin, Evangelical Protestant Society, Belfast
WHATEVER HAPPENED TO HEAVEN?, Dave Hunt, Harvest House, Eugene, Oregon, 1988